Nothing is more POLITICAL than this

Can we be done with this imbecility of let's not politicize tragedy? It is utterly political. In fact, nothing is more political than this man-made tragedy.

Who gets to make policy decisions regarding essential infrastructure (such as work on levees in the country's largest port vs. bridges to empty islands in Alaska), who gets to make policy and funding decisions for disaster preparation, and who gets to make the decisions when disaster strikes -- all of this is a consequence of politics.

Politics is not an empty game of words that's played independently of policy and events. This is when we need politics the most. Policy and decision-making must change. We can't have blithering idiots with no relevant experience running critical agencies just because they are Republican political cronies -- part and parcel of the Republican culture of corruption.

Policy will only change if power changes, and power will only change as a consequence of politics.

Until Democrats go on the attack, as ruthlessly as imaginable, people will not trust them as leaders who can fight. And the media, in the sad state it currently is, will not respect them either. If Democrats can't fight for themselves, and be willing to take a few hits in the process if need be, no one will trust them to fight for the country.

Democrats must call for Bush's resignation, now.

Not that he will, but it's the only decent thing to do and, at this point, it's also good politics. And get over the politicization-phobia. The GOP has a long time ago. It's how they gained their current hold on absolute power in spite of staggering incompetence on policy and decision-making.

Democrats must fight and hurt the GOP for the consequences of their policies and budget decisions. It's good politics and, right now, good politics is the only way to get the good policy and good decision-making that the country desperately needs.

(Finally, here's a suggested link for the Trolls to go do something more useful instead of coming here to repeat GOP talking points.)



Display:


Tip of the hat (none / 0)

With a tip of the hat to MeanBoneII.

by miholo on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 06:42:59 PM EST

the unity plea (3.00 / 1)

Whenever the Republicans Screw Up they instantly plea ot the people for Unity.  And the Dems fall for it every stinkin time.

This is not a time for unity it is a time for outrage and action!

DAGGER
by goplies on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 06:46:52 PM EST

Re: the unity plea (none / 0)

Whenever anyone says

"now is not the time for blame and finger pointing"

odds are they are the ones who screwed up.

by wayward on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 09:38:27 PM EST
[ Parent ]

New Deal Coalition (again) (none / 0)

If the Democrats play this right, laying the blame on Bush (where it should be), we could have another New Deal coalition.  His presidency is severely crippled by this.  He dropped the ball at the critical moment.  There will be a lot more blue states in 2008.
Max Friedman
by Max Friedman on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 08:35:42 PM EST

Don't bet too much on it (none / 0)

Don't bet too much on it. If Dems continue silent, two weeks from now the right-wing noise machine will have spun this into another great example of Bush's leadership.

The photo ops are already working to shore up Bush's support, see most recent poll, compared with last week's polls. (And these were the photo ops which grounded all helicopters in NOLA for hours, and included staging fake food distribution points and fake repairs of the levee just for the duration of the photo op -- all of which was a diversion of resources that must have killed dozens of people at least. Landrieu complained about this, the blogs were over it, some foreign media gave overtly disgusted first-person accounts of it, but not a peep on it in the US media.)

Never underestimate what a well-coordinated media machine and a compliant media can do. And, with a GOP-controlled Congress, you can forget about meaningful hearings.

Democratic leadership seems to be lazily waiting to win by default after Bush falls. It just won't happen. Unless the Dems stop acting like dogs who've been beat too much, and get into the knife-fight that the GOP is willing to make of every issue, it just won't happen.

by miholo on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 08:59:11 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Republicans are a different species (none / 0)

This makes no sense:

Bush's Response to Katrina

                       Approve    Disapprove
All                       46%         47%
Democrats           17            71
Independents       44            48
Republicans          74            22

If 74% of Republicans approve of Bush's response to Katrina, what would it take for them to disapprove of his response? Would they approve of his response if he was still vacationing in Crawford?

by Gary Boatwright on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 09:18:16 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Republicans are a different species (none / 0)

He would be remaining calm in a crisis.
by wayward on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 09:40:12 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Republicans are a different species (none / 0)

There's maybe 1/3 of the population for whom Bush could kill a puppy live on TV and they would still worship him. Those are lost.

But there's a group of 10 or 15 pct who wavered on thu and fri, as the SUSA poll shows. But the dems stayed silent and failed to lock in the perception people had in that moment in people's memory. Now the GOP will be relentlessly reshaping people's image and perception of it, shifting blame to the local authoerities, with the media only too happy to enable it.

It's disgusting that dem politicians are not standing up with outrage to support Landrieu and Blanco against the GOP smear campaign.

At this point let's just hope they do enough to avoid Bush getting a bounce - which is not unlikely with a couple of weeks of photo ops and a complicit Congress.

by miholo on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 10:55:42 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Our Conscience (none / 0)

Republicans are always using the Dems Real conscience against them. Remember the Governors race in Maryland during the sniper episode.

The Conservative philosophy will continue to create huge problems for America. Survival is completely political.

by tchoup on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 10:46:04 PM EST

Re: Our Conscience (none / 0)

The Democratic class in Washington still hasn't realized that the good of the country does not require unity. It requires an opposition party. The GOP is playing by different rules, always willing to damage the country if they have to to win, winning every time, and indeed damaging the country.
by miholo on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 11:03:46 PM EST
[ Parent ]

SUSA poll update (none / 0)

Bush's bad numbers are holding up in today's SUSA poll, 38 approve, 55 disaprove his handling of the crisis. We'll have to wait for a 3rd poll.

Given all that went down, 55 is still disapointing. But maybe there's still hope - if the Dems start acting like an opposition party now.

by miholo on Sun Sep 04, 2005 at 11:42:20 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.